"The Saturday Reblter."
MANY of our readers have heard of a periodical styled "The Saturday Review." Its sphere is remote from our own. As, however, it has occasionally wandered into our orbit, we propose to pay it a short visit in return. Once, and again, and again, it has endeavoured to attract our attention, by its comments on the sayings and doings of Mr. Spurgeon, and recently, by its observations upon his "Lecture on Candles." Having now a sword of our own, as well as a trowel, we shall be expected to show that we bear not the sword in vain. We can hardly be supposed to be so expert in the use of this weapon as those who have no other; but we hope to supply by calmness and confidence in the goodness of our cause what may be wanting in skill. To mere threatenings and intrigues, our reply is, "We are doing a great work so that we cannot come down;" but when openly and directly attacked, we yield not to fear.
Our object here is to exhibit the writers of this periodical from our point of view, as they have often favoured us with our appearance from theirs; and we do not think this could be better expressed than by urging upon them the proposal to change the title from "The Saturday Review," to that of "The Saturday Reviler." We believe that its first name was appropriate at the time. It was general and arbitrary, as names usually are when given before birth. We must wait for a characteristic title until the full character appears. It is because of the full development of its distinguishing peculiarity that we recommend the change of title to which we have adverted. We shall endeavour to make good these two assertions—that "The Saturday Review" was a well chosen title at first, and that "The Saturday Reviler" would be the more appropriate appellation now. Its first title was indefinite. It engrossed no opinions, and was committed to none; and in this respect was admirably suited to the design of its projectors. It left them at liberty to say anything and everything, without the violation of a principle or a promise, expressed or understood. It was deceptive. It concealed the principal agents, as far as possible, from view. It was no patronymic, by which its parentage could be known. There was none of the pride of those who "call their lands after their own names." Similar titles we have had to periodicals, but the parties represented by them have been known; for the sentiments of "The Saturday Review," the public has no guarantee. Its works are in the dark. It vehemently assails the persons of others, but has no personality of its own. The first title was pretentious. This must be affirmed of every periodical which claims to be nothing more than a review. It requires to have no opinions of its own, except upon the opinions of others. It may assume, as in the instance before us, a dictatorship in the whole world of letters. True, the ancient critics yet remain. They have Quintilian, Cicero, and Longinus. Let them hear them? No! They have Bacon, Locke, and Newton. Let them hear them? No! They have "The Athenæum," "The Edinburgh Review," and "The British Quarterly." Let them hear them? No! What then? Let them hear "The Saturday Review." This is its oracular tone; and even this would be more tolerable if it had some fixed principles of its own.
199
Its first title was suggestive. It may be wondered how this can apply to so general a title as "The Saturday Review," but it is difficult even for the most artful to suppress every glimpse of their design. "By thy words thou shalt be justified, and by thy words thou shalt be condemned." "The Saturday Review," was morally suggestive. It would be replete with all that could elevate the mind above the secular cares of the week, and contribute to its preparation for the Sabbath. Might it not also prove acceptable in the circles to which it aspired on the Sabbath itself? At any rate, there could be no harm in placing such a temptation in their way. Taking this suggestion in connection with the miscellaneous character of the review, as embracing all subjects in the political, fashionable, and sporting world, and all in religion except real religion itself, we are at no loss to perceive its standard of moral excellence and its opinion of the high destiny of man.
We have seen that the title of "The Saturday Review" was as suited to the design of its original promoters, as any our vocabulary could afford. Having now acquired a character of its own, it is due to itself, and to the public, that a more characteristic title should be assumed. That of "The Saturday Reviler" has been suggested. It involves no other alteration in the typography than the change of one letter and the addition of another. It is particularly apposite. It faithfully represents its guardian spirit, and its own. In science and in art, as well as in ordinary life, things are called according to their distinguishing features. We do not wrong a contemporary publication, therefore, by suggesting this title, but act upon a rule by which we ourselves are willing to be tried. None, we presume, would resort to it for scientific information, or literary taste, much less for moral teaching, and least of all for religious training; but if they love scandal and abuse, they will find it to their heart's content. Nothing sells better amongst the half-educated population than abuse, and especially when directed against those who are better than themselves. Upon this principle, without doubt, the calculations of "The Saturday Reviler" have been founded. The art of reviling by no means requires either great talent, or scholarship. A superior order of mind will not descend to it. It will indulge in occasional satire, but not defile itself with abuse. "The Saturday Reviler" revels in it. Here it is most at home. It is natural for writers to select those topics that best lie within the compass of their abilities, and in which they can indulge in their favourite strain. Every animal seeks food most congenial to its taste, and its elevation in the scale of being may in general be determined by that upon which it feeds. Such as love reviling certainly have a moral nature of their own. Do plants send forth their roots to a great distance when they find not the assimilating particles near at hand? Do animals when at liberty wander far in search of the food that is convenient for them? Precisely thus, "The Saturday Reviler" sends forth its tendrils or its foragers, to keep up the needful supply. This accounts for its appearance occasionally at the Metropolitan Tabernacle. Look at its recent article upon the "Lecture on Candles." Here was nothing, we should have supposed, which the most consummate practitioner in reviling among men, could have vilified and traduced. There was, as in everything else, much to misrepresent and misapply,
and of this, abundant use is made. What should lead "The Saturday Reviler" to the Metropolitan Tabernacle but its own innate love for reviling? What has Mr. Spurgeon done to excite its hatred and abuse? He has not asked its leave to exist, or to live in the same country and age, or to preach, or to proclaim his own sentiments in his own way. He has not gone to its office to acquire his theology, or authority to make it known. He has dared to act as though no such tribunal had been erected. He has positively ignored it altogether. It has counselled mildly, it has raised its warning voice, it has thundered forth its anathemas, it has calumniated, it has ejected its venom, and still he treats it as a thing of nought. It tries to arrest his progress, and finds that he advances only the more. Now if it really wishes to do him harm, as we believe it does, we will advise it what to do. Let it say everything in his favour; for its praise would be far more condemnatory than its blame. It is not from a Metropolitan Tabernacle point of view merely, that the title of "Saturday Reviler" can be justified. Let similar good be done in any other direction, and a similar onslaught is made. Evangelical truth, wherever it may exist, is the professed object of its hatred and scorn; and civil law, as its own history testifies, is the only restraint upon its defamation of the persons who are most prominent in its diffusion. Let us hear no more then of "The Saturday Review;" let it be everywhere known to be what it really is—"The Saturday Reviler."
G. ROGERS.
