Calvinism Defended — By G. Rogers, Tutor Of The Metropolitan Tabernacle College




THE publication of the sermons of Mr. Henry Ward Beecher in this country cannot fail to attract considerable attention on account both of the literary peculiarities, and of the general celebrity of the author. It becomes us, therefore, to consider how far it is calculated to affect the English pulpit, and to advance the best interests of Christianity amongst us. As an importation of new beauties of speech, of apt illustration, of moral discrimination and of practical piety, we confess to a positive gain; but in a theological point of view, we are bound to regard it as a considerable item on the other side. In the first volume, we have not proceeded far before we meet with a professed attack upon the Calvinistic creed. This would seem to demand some distinct notice by us, seeing that we are set for the defence of this gospel, and that we may not be supposed to bear "the Sword and the Trowel" in vain. We allude to the fifth sermon of the series, entitled, "God our Father," in which the universal Fatherhood of God, in a certain theological sense well known as a modern innovation amongst us, is fully and strenuously maintained.
Let us hear his own words: "The New Testament teaches us that the aspect of God, in which he is Father and we are children, is the one that is to be most familiarly used. Of all the aspects of God in the Bible, those which present him as a Governor and as a Father, are the two which predominate over all the others. And it will be my object to show you that the aspect of God as a Father is the one on which you ought to base your instructions in the family, and the one on which you ought to build Christian life. You are to keep before your mind, not God as your governor, not God as your king, not God as your judge, but God as your Father. . . . It is a peculiarity of Calvinism to present God in universal relations. It does not include the paternity of God, but it has presented with such ability and intensity, and in such proportions, the magisterial character of God, that this is the view which it has most strongly impressed upon men; and those who have been brought up under New England teaching, are apt to think of God in his relations to government. What is called God's moral government is the texture out of which the sermons of Calvinistic preachers are largely made. But to think of God as a governor, is to make him an abstract being. Even upon earth the governor of a state is an abstraction. . . . The governor stands without any regard to who is in it. It has no personality. It is not allowed to have any. It is as nearly as possible the abstract administration of certain laws. . . . Now you may love a man that is governor; but no man can love the governor. Governor is an official title and not a personal one; and if you train yourself to think of God as an official personage, the soul does not go out after him. The heart does not twine around abstractions. . . . It makes a great deal of difference whether you draw your rules for measuring sin, and the desert of sin, from a government administered over a state, or from a government administered over a household, from
a government administered by a father, or from a government administered by a ruler. The family then, and not the state, is the fittest model for contemplation."
Much more might be quoted to the same effect. You have in these citations the substance of the whole discourse, and to these, or the principles involved in them, our observations will be entirely confined. We admit that the doctrines of Calvinism are founded upon the moral government of God; that it knows nothing of the universal fatherhood of God in its evangelical signification; that its creed is based upon the governmental, rather than upon the paternal, aspect of the Divine Being; and that in these respects, Mr. Beecher's views are essentially different from our own. The question now rises, which is more accordant with the Scriptures of truth?
1. We maintain that subjects of the highest moment are not left in Scripture to be determined by any single figurative representation of the relation of God to man; nor by all the analogies between human and divine agencies; but by plain and direct propositions and reasonings. God is not to be viewed, either as a governor or a father, strictly after the human model. "His thoughts are not as our thoughts, neither are his ways as our ways." Mr. Beecher's argument is founded upon a precise similarity. Abstractedly considered, the contrast far exceeds the resemblance; and the contrast may be just where the argument of analogy is supposed to receive its greatest force. We are not left to gather our first principles from Scripture by analogical reasoning, but from plainly recorded facts. The character of God both as a governor and a father is to be interpreted by his own descriptions of those figures as applicable to him, and not as they are generally known to us. To rest a whole system of theology upon a fancied relationship of God to man, similar to that which his creatures sustain to each other, is to build upon drifting sand. Yet says Mr. Beecher, "The aspect of God as a Father is the one on which you ought to build Christian life." On which; not with which, after the foundation has been laid. The fatherly character of God is to be the foundation of your hopes. This we hold not to be the direct teaching of the Word of God.
2. We are not disposed to accept the metaphysical distinction between a governor and a father, for which Mr. Beecher contends: he says that "A governor is an abstract being"—"it is an official title and not a personal one," and when you consider God as the governor of the universe, you must make him impersonal; implying of course that considered as a father, he is not an abstraction, but of necessity, a personality. This notion is derived from the fact that the laws govern independently of the consideration of who the governor may be. The parental rule is concentrated in the parent; the civil law is not concentrated in the king or judge. With the parent, the parental authority ceases; with the governor, the governmental authority does not cease. Then is there not more of personality in one than in the other? This is the argument in its full force; but what does it really amount to? It is partly true in theory, but as a basis of theological truth it is utterly worthless. It is just where the analogy between human offices and the Divine fails, that the argument is made to rest. It is not always true that the governor is an abstraction in the govern-
141
ment, and seldom if ever completely so. In popular forms of government it may be so to a great extent; but it is to absolute, rather than to dependent governors that God is compared in the scriptures, such as prevailed in the East, in which the governor and the government were the same. Neither the Pharaohs nor the Artaxerxes of old Testament, nor the Caesars of New Testament times, were considered as impersonalities or abstractions. Why may not a parent be considered as an abstraction too, since the parental government is, or ought to be, the same, whoever the parent may be, and should have an influence upon the child, whether the parent be present or absent, and even after his decease? This distinction does not therefore hold good amongst men. Does Mr. Beecher really consider Mr. Abraham Lincoln a mere abstraction or impersonality whom he can neither reverence nor love? Does he really consider the parent, and the parental laws to be identically the same? Supposing, however, the distinction he makes between a governor and a father to exist among men, it could not apply to God whose laws are an emanation from himself, and an expression of his own nature and will. It may be poetic and rhetorical to speak of God as an impersonal Governor and a personal Father, but most assuredly it cannot be according to truth.
3. We deny that the character of God as a Father is the one that is predominant in scripture, and is the principal aspect in which he should be looked upon by sinful men. This is the first principle upon which the whole reasoning in this new system of theology is built; and which ought not to have been taken for granted. In fact, to sustain the whole theory it ought to be shown that the paternal is the only relation in which God stands to the race of man; instead of which we find it to be but one of numerous titles given to the Divine Being, neither more frequently nor emphatically than many others. If this one had sufficed, why so many others? And why some as king and judge of an opposite kind.
We have no hesitation in affirming that the character of God as a moral governor is that in which he is most prominently exhibited throughout the whole scriptures; it is his chief aspect both in the law and the gospel; it is the form in which he demands our faith and obedience; it is the source both of his promises and threatenings; and it is the aspect under which all creatures must chiefly contemplate him. Let it be remembered, however, that the moral government of God embraces both equity and sovereignty. The character of God as a Governor is not confined to law. The gospel is as much a part of the moral government of God as the law; and if Calvinists are deemed rigorous and austere, because they demand grace and all the tender mercies of God to be exercised in conformity with strict justice, they glory in the consistency of their views with the whole character and the whole word of God. Mr. Beecher's view of God as a governor is as a lawgiver and a judge only, ours is as a gracious sovereign as well as a just ruler. The parental relation with us is part of the moral government, and not separated from it. We see no reason why governors should not be parental as well as judicial, and particularly why God as a universal governor should be more a God of justice than of love.
4. We do not find any encouragement to men to seek pardon from God on the ground of any parental relation he sustains to them, to be the teaching of the Bible. The thought that he is their creator only aggravates their guilt. His goodness, which should lead them to repentance, is general and not paternal. In the law, God speaks to them as a judge; in the gospel as a sovereign. So far from being addressed as children of God, they are styled "Children of wrath," "Children of disobedience," and "Children of the devil." The parable of the prodigal son has been supposed to represent the relation in which God stands to men in general, but a little examination will suffice to prove that it admits of a different interpretation. Nowhere does God say to sinners "Oh my rebellious children! my wandering, my deluded sons and daughters! Return to your Father's bosom, and your Father's house! Ease his disconsolate heart. Return at once, and all shall be forgiven. The past shall no more be remembered. Only return, and henceforth we shall live in love and happiness for ever!" What it does say is, "Come out from among them, and be ye separate, saith the Lord, and touch not the unclean thing; and I will receive you, and will be a Father unto you, and ye shall be my sons and daughters saith the Lord Almighty." It says not come because I am, but because I will be, a Father unto you; not because ye are, but because ye shall be my sons and daughters. What it does say is, "As many as received him to them gave he power to become the sons of God," implying they had not that power before. Observe in what that power consists! "which were born not of blood, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God." They who are born of man, therefore, are not in new Testament language the children of God. Again what the scripture does say is, "Beloved now are we the sons of God." This now implies that they were not sons before. What it does say is, "As many as are led by the spirit of God, they are the sons of God. For ye have not received the spirit of bondage to fear; but ye have received the spirit of adoption, whereby we cry, Abba, Father." The teaching of these words is, that by the renewing and guiding influence of the Spirit of God we become the sons of God; implying of course that we had not that privilege before; and further, that the Spirit gives us an inward consciousness of our relation to God as our Father; and further still, that we are brought into this new relation by adoption. Yet this is the passage upon which Mr. Beecher grounds his views of the universal Fatherhood of God. He speaks at times, as though we became the children of God in conversion; and yet the drift of his whole discourse is to show the duty of all men to look upon God as their Father, and to merge all other considerations of the relations of God to them in this one. It is remarkable, did we not know that preachers of this order are carried away by natural and sympathetic feeling with the multitude, that the fact of believers being the children of God by adoption should not have suggested that they are not so by nature, since men invariably adopt the children of strangers and not their own. It might further be shown that the filial relation of fallen man to God is restored in no other way than by actual union to Christ, according to the apostolic declaration, "Ye are all the children of God by faith in Christ Jesus." But sufficient has been said, we trust, to
143
prove that the aspect of God as a Father to men in general, instead of being the one most appropriate to them and most just, is erroneous both in principle and practice. It is the mercy of a forgiving Lord, more merciful even than an injured parent, that they are invited to seek.
5. The distinguishing peculiarities of the gospel harmonize more with the character of God as a moral governor than as a universal father. The paternal relation considered by itself, precludes indeed the necessity of reconciliation by mediation, and pardon by vicarious sacrifice. Nothing more would be required than the declaration, "Father, I have sinned," as with the prodigal son; and hence the strongest points of the evangelical system are reduced to almost nothing by theologians of this school. A father does not require an innocent son to stand in the place of one that has sinned; a father does not need an atoning sacrifice to be offered as the ground of reconciliation to his own son; a father does not require the service of another in the place of that which he lost by the disobedience of a child before he forgives him; a father does not demand the payment of the portion of goods wasted by the prodigal son of another before he embraces him. If that therefore be the chief aspect of God to men, then is the offence of the cross ceased, and Christ has died in vain. If such had been the principal relation of God to man, how easy it would have been for inspiration to have so stated it! Instead of this, we read, "Christ is all and in all;" "That in all things he might have the pre-eminence;" "He of God is made unto us wisdom, righteousness, sanctification, and redemption;" "The life which I live in the flesh I live by the faith of the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me;" and numerous passages of the same kind. In vain shall we try to reconcile such declarations with the character of God as a Father; in vain seek for analogies with them in the parental relations of men. Look, on the other hand, upon the character of God as a moral governor, and the plan of redemption is in beautiful harmony with all the great principles of his government, and illustrative of the highest glories of his nature. Here are the loftiest displays both of justice and of grace, and of the union of both in a God who is love. This is the Calvinism, not of John Calvin merely, but of the New Testament.
6. We have a strong persuasion that the results of the preaching adopted by Mr. Beecher are far less hopeful than of that which he condemns. The New England teaching from which he professes to have departed, will not suffer from a comparison in this respect with his own. Of this same New England, we would ask, Received ye the Spirit by the Calvinistic teaching of Jonathan Edwards, of David Brainerd, of Dr. Payson, of Nathaniel Nettleton, or by the preaching of Henry Ward Beecher? In every country and in every age, we maintain, it has been received, not by the works of the law, but by the hearing of faith. The genuine effects of preaching have ever depended more upon the doctrines than the men. Whitfield's oratory, without his Calvinism, would not have had such great and permanent results, and Wesley's usefulness was the fruit of the measure of Calvinism he retained. It is not by the preaching of those doctrines merely that good effects are secured, but by the prayerful dependence upon the grace of God which necessarily
accompanies them. These are the truths, we hesitate not to affirm, that the Spirit of God employs for the conversion of sinners, for the consolation of believers, and for the joy of the redeemed amidst the terrors of the last day. Are the sentiments derived from the universal Fatherhood of God equally powerful? Will the hopes founded upon them abide the same test? We confidently answer, No! It is true of doctrines as well as of men, that "By their fruits ye shall know them."
