Menu
‹ Chapter 228 of 241 ›

On the Righteousness of God — By G. Rogers

15 min read · Chapter 228 of 241
On the Righteousness of God — By G. Rogers

IN our observations in a former article upon the doctrines connected with Plymouth Brethrenism, we referred to the source from which our information was derived. We were not responsible therefore for their affiliation. We wrote with the impression, “Are these things so?” Can it be that such sentiments are held by those who profess of all saints to be most pure? Communications have reached us from parties who complain of having been misrepresented, which have tended rather to confirm our persuasion that these things are so. It is no gratification to us to know that the accusation was just. Would that it were otherwise! Happy should we be to learn that this most sectarian of all sects devoted its whole efforts and zeal to the dissemination of a pure gospel. We should then rejoice in the end they had in view, however much we might condemn the means they employed. We should rank them with those who preach Christ even of envy and strife, and in whose preaching, though not in themselves, we should have some reason to rejoice.

The principal error in Plymouth Brethrenism is in relation to the righteousness for justification, which, as it is a cardinal point, and the chief test of orthodoxy, of necessity throws derangement into every other part of the Christian system. It is to a deviation from this point that Paul gives the title of another gospel, and of which he says, whoever preaches it, be he a man or angel, would be accursed. Yet upon this subject, according to their own confession, this new sect has not been misrepresented by us. The peculiar views of the righteousness of justification attributed to them have been acknowledged, and endeavoured to be defended in the private communications we have received, and are boldly advocated in a pamphlet recently sent to us. This pamphlet is entitled, “The Righteousness of God: what is it?” Its author is a Mr. W. Kelly, an approved champion of the new faith. Upon this whole production we should cheerfully comment, if space permitted. Some specimens only of its sentiments and the manner in which they are sustained, will be given.

It begins with the assumption that the righteousness of God is a much disputed point. It is disputed we grant by some, but by all evangelical Christians it is held to be a settled article of belief. The insinuation that it is an open question among true Christians may serve the author’s purpose, but is not according to truth. Neither is it true

527

that the righteousness of God is not generally understood. It is well understood by those who are truly justified; and evangelical preachers and writers agree in their statements and reasonings upon the subject. The righteousness of justification, they hold, is the righteousness of Christ, not as God, but procured by him as a substitute in the place of transgressors, and imputed to all who believe in him for that end. As he who obeyed the law of God on their behalf was God as well as man, and was appointed by God to that work and with that design, the righteousness of his obedience, they maintain, may be justly styled the righteousness of God. Upon this belief all evangelical Christians agree. It is so grand and simple an object of belief that it admits not of shades of opinion or degrees. It cannot be held in part, or in any modified sense. It must be received or rejected as a whole. There is no other righteousness of God than of God himself as a moral governor, or of the Godman. The righteousness of God, as God simply, could in no sense become that of the creature. The righteousness of the Godman must be solely for the benefit of those for whom that character was assumed. Either Christ was a full substitute for his people, or none at all. A partial substitute is out of the question. If a partial substitute were provided there might as well have been none at all. If he were a real substitute he must be and do all that the strictest justice could require of those whose substitute he became. The demands of justice for their justification were that all they had done should be undone, and all should be done that they had failed to do; in other words that the full penalty of their disobedience should be endured, and the full obedience originally due from them should be performed. We do not state these truths because they are not known, but to show that a slight deviation from them is impossible, and that to reject them in part is to reject them altogether or to preach another gospel. We see nothing, in fact, between the entire substitutionary character of Christ's person and work and his becoming a mere teacher and example among men. To be consistent, we must adopt the whole evangelical, or the whole unitarian, creed. All attempts to find a settled basis between these two extremes have signally failed. Modifications of the great evangelical truths have been attempted by many in our day, through the pride of reason on the one hand, or the vanity of imagination on the other, but they have no settled foundation, and they assume no permanent form. "Their rock is not as our rock." "If the foundations be destroyed, what can the righteous do?"

Mr. Kelly, as the oracle of Plymouth Brethrenism, emphatically repudiates the evangelical interpretation of the righteousness of justification, labors to show that no such meaning can be properly attributed to the passages of scripture usually quoted for that purpose, and favors us with his own corrected and infallible explanation of them. He does not argue so much from what is said, as from what is not said. He exults continually at not finding the very words in which faith in the imputed righteousness of Christ for justification is usually spoken of; and he does not know the doctrine when he meets with it in any other form. He is amazed to think that the church should so long have walked in darkness where to him all things are clear. Satisfied, however, as he appears to be with the conclusiveness of his own reasoning, he has not the capacity for making it equally convincing to others. A writer

who substitutes declamation for argument, who frequently pauses to admire the wisdom of his own discoveries and to wonder at the stupidity of others, and who has no broad and well defined principles to supercede those which he endeavours to overthrow, is not easy to follow in disputation; and amongst such authors Mr. Kelly holds an unenviable superiority.

A few instances of his reasoning may suffice. When man lost his righteousness "it becomes," he says, "a question of another kind of righteousness altogether." This assertion is intended to prove that the righteousness of man's justification is the righteousness of God only; but upon what is it founded? There is no attempt to prove that it must be another kind of righteousness altogether. The very notion is absurd. The same kind of righteousness that was required of man at first is required of him still. It may come from a different source, but the righteousness is of the same kind. It is the righteousness required by the same law, and therefore in all respects the same. One kind of righteousness could not be substituted for another, as that of an angel for a man, or of a servant for a child. The righteousness to justify must be that which the justified themselves ought to have performed.

In explanation of Paul's reasoning upon this subject, in the latter part of the third chapter of the Epistle to the Romans, we read, "That the Saviour came down from heaven and accomplished the law is the certain truth of God." Here, as in many other instances, we should have supposed the whole truth to be admitted. But mark the sequel! "But is this what the Holy Ghost here presents as God's righteousness? Where is there a word about Christ's keeping the law for us, in order that this should be accepted in lieu of man's failure?" Where! Why here in this very chapter. How otherwise could it be styled the righteousness of God by faith of Jesus Christ unto all and upon all them that believe? How otherwise could it be said that "God had set him forth to declare his righteousness for the remission of sins?" How otherwise that he might be just and the justifier of him which believeth in Jesus. What has faith in Christ to do with our justification? Why is God just in justifying those who believe in him, if that justification be not on account of something which he has done on their behalf? and as righteousness is the only ground of justification, it must be on account of the righteousness that is in him. Let us see now what our author makes the righteousness here mentioned to be. Here he says is God's answer, "it is the righteousness of God without law. No language can be more absolute and precise. What the Holy Ghost employs is an expression which puts the law entirely aside, as far as divine righteousness is concerned. He had been speaking about the law, and the law condemning man. He had shown that the law required righteousness but could not get it. This is another order of righteousness, not man's but God's, and this too absolutely exclusive of law in any shape." Who ever before heard of a righteousness in this sense without law? What is righteousness but conformity to law? Even the righteousness of God is conformity with the laws of his own being. If when there is no law there is no transgression, so where there is no law there can be no righteousness. The law, it is here acknowledged, "required righteousness but could not get it." If the

529

righteousness of man's justification be absolutely without law, the law must still and for ever go without the righteousness it requires. How can there be justification of any kind irrespective of law? "Without the law" evidently means without man's own obedience to the law; corresponding with what is soon after affirmed, "that a man is justified by faith without the deeds of the law;" and in the following chapter, "unto whom God imputeth righteousness without works," not absolutely exclusive of works, but as far as man is concerned and entirely by the works of another.

The evangelical theory of justification is not assailed in this pamphlet, because it is not clearly understood. Would that the writer as clearly understood his own creed! "Listen to the man," he says, "who holds the popular doctrine on the subject: does he conceal the distinctive feature? Does he keep back Christ's observance of the law for us? On the contrary, it is the uppermost idea, and continually pressed in his discourses. It is the law kept by Christ, he tells you, which specially and alone constitutes the righteousness of the believer before God. He does not deny that the blood of Christ is the means of the sinner's pardon; but then it will never do, he argues, to approach heaven with pardon merely; one must have righteousness also, and this for him is found in the legal obedience of Christ. Thus if it is a question of justifying, (and in general the popular theology sharply distinguishes between the two things,) his justification is made to depend on the fact that Christ kept the law for him, which he could not keep for himself, that Christ omitted no duty of his, and performed all perfectly in which he himself failed." We accept this as a faithful representation of our principles. The way in which it is met, is a fair specimen of the author's reasoning. "But how comes it to pass," he says, "that God does not put the matter thus?" taking it for granted that he does not, and deeming it impossible for the same truths to be put in different words. He replies, "Because it is not the truth. Nothing more simple, if it be not the truth," meaning, we presume, if it be the truth. "It is the truth that man has failed in every way; it is the truth that Christ obeyed the law of God; it is not the truth that even his keeping of the law is the real sense of God's righteousness, or the ground of our justification before God." These are oracular sayings, and if others are not convinced by them, the fault, it is more than suggested, must be their own. We confess that we are not entirely silenced by them. We venture to affirm, in our turn, "that God does put the matter thus." It is the truth we are told, that Christ obeyed the law of God, and it is not the truth that his keeping the law is the ground of our justification before God. For whom then did Christ obey the law? Was it for himself or his people? For himself, our author says, but we see no difference between the two. All that he did in his person as Immanuel, was as the representative of his people, and therefore was on their behalf. We are told that his obedience was his qualification as a spotless oblation for the sin of man, but the benefit of that obedience is not the less for others. If pardon through the atoning death of Christ be alone admitted, which is one principal doctrine here maintained, for the purpose of putting him aside as "The Lord our righteousness," why should that atonement

need to be preceded by a perfect obedience, if the obedience itself as well as the sacrifice were not to be set to his people's account? He did obey the law; he did suffer the penalty of the law; whatever he did was for others; these others therefore derive the proper fruit of both. The fruit of suffering is pardon, the fruit of obedience is justification. The obedience of Christ, and it is admitted he did obey the law, must have been for his own justification or theirs; if his own, it was as their representative, and consequently for their justification in him. Christ must suffer, because his people were required to suffer; and he must obey, because his people were required to obey. In the one he was regarded by the law as guilty, in the other as righteous. The two, therefore, are not to be confounded, and may properly be regarded in principle, however closely connected in operation, as distinct grounds of pardon and justification. "We have Christ," it is here said, "as a whole. We have his obedience unbroken through his entire life, and its savour unto God is part of the blessing that belongs to every child of God." Now if the obedience of Christ be part of the blessing that belongs to every child of God, what other end can that obedience serve him than for his justification? The admissions and disavowals of the same sentiments is one of the most remarkable features of this whole treatise. Thus, soon after the declaration we have quoted, that the keeping of the law by Christ is not the ground of our justification before God, we have these words:—"What plainer than the truth that God accounts us righteous by virtue of Christ's work?"

As an instance of the manner in which writers of this school confound pardon with justification, take the following quotation: "What God gives, what he could not do without, is precisely what man wants as a sinner." So say we. But mark the next sentence! "It is not well-doing, were it even the blessed Lord's in place of our sins and guilt. The sinner wants a propitiatory before God, and finds it through faith in the blood of Jesus." The sinner does not want the well-doing of Christ, he wants his propitiatory offering only. This is the doctrine of Mr. Kelly and his brethren. That there was well-doing in Christ is acknowledged, but the sinner did not want it. Then who did want it? If Christ wanted it, it must have been for his own sake or his people's. If for his own sake, as Christ, we repeat, it must have been for the sake of his people. If they could have dispensed with his well-doing; much more could he. What man wants as a sinner, is both well-doing and propitiation. He wants the latter to remove his guilt, he wants the former to make him at once, and for ever, legally righteous. Pardon, through a propitiation, restores him to the position from which he fell, justification through well-doing does for him what the completion of his own obedience would have done. Adam was just, but could not have been fully justified, until the term of his probation was complete. Therefore pardon, which simply removes past guilt, makes just, but does not justify; in other words it makes an end of sin, but does not bring in an everlasting righteousness.

Though propitiation is here said to be all the sinner wants, justification in some sort is conceded. "That he might be just and the justifier of him which believeth in Jesus," is thus explained. "Who might be just? Is it Christ just? or is it God just by virtue of Christ? It is

531

that God might be just. It is God that justificeth. It is therefore 'The righteousness of God, without a hint of transferring to us the legal righteousness of Christ. It is by virtue of Christ, or God could not be thus righteous in behalf of the sinner.' The righteousness of God in justifying is one thing, and the righteousness on account of which he justifies is another. The former depends upon the latter. These two are confounded through the whole of our author's reasoning. He says it is by virtue of his own righteousness that God justifies, and immediately afterwards it is by virtue of Christ's. What he means by this is the righteousness in redemption, which, even admitting the confusion of terms, supposes a righteousness in him on account of which sinners are justified. There is no hint, we are told, in this passage of transferring to us the legal righteousness of Christ. He must be dull indeed in taking a hint, to whom something of the kind is not suggested by the words, "and the justifier of him which believeth in Jesus." Why justify him which believeth in Jesus? Why is God just in justifying such, and such only? Why are sinners to believe in him for justification? It must be either because there is righteousness in Christ to justify them, or righteousness in their own act of faith in him. The latter, with strange inconsistency, is maintained by some, as though there were merit in believing what overwhelming evidence requires us to believe; and still the question would return, why not equal merit in other acts of faith? The object here, it may be said, gives it merit. Very true! but then the merit lies in the object and not in the act of faith. If in the object, it must be in a righteousness to be found there, which faith appropriates and God imputes to the sinner for his justification. This is a broad hint, we think, of the legal righteousness of Christ being transferred to us. There could be no need to send Christ to make God's righteousness greater. If on the ground of his own righteousness he justifies the sinner, he could do it without Christ, for Christ did not make any addition to that righteousness; but if he justifies for the sake of Christ, it must have been on the ground of some other righteousness that was found in him. Then as for the continual reiteration of the sentiment that scripture makes no mention of the righteousness of Christ being a legal provision for the justification of the sinner, what shall be said of those words: "Christ is the end of the law for righteousness to every one that believeth." "Why not tell us," says Mr. Kelly on these words, "of fulfilling it?" Why, man alive! what is the end of a law but its fulfilment? Its ultimate end is the reward of obedience and the punishment of disobedience. The end here is said to be for righteousness, and that righteousness of Christ resulting from his fulfilling the law, is for every one that believeth.

We might proceed to show similar perversions of other Scripture declarations upon this doctrine; and shall readily do so if required. The strangest notions, after the fashion of interpreters of this school, are introduced to neutralize the bearing of the comparison of Christ with Adam as a covenant head in the writings of Paul upon this subject. The passage too in the second Epistle to the Corinthians, "He hath made him to be sin for us who knew no sin that we might be made the righteousness of God in him" is one over which the writer falls, and which if it fell on him, would grind him to powder.

1

The confidence with which this whole pamphlet is written justifies a little confidence on our part in return. Observe the triumphant strain towards its close "Without slighting any good man, and with a certain knowledge of the best men's writings in most ages, I may say confidently that this legal theory is the mill-stone about the necks of most moderns." In John Owen and Richard Baxter there was, perhaps, equal lack of light as to the righteousness of God." "Not one of the Puritan class could say intelligently with the apostle, 'Though we have known Christ after the flesh, yet now henceforth know we him no more.'" These men, even the greatest of them, it is intimated, were wanting in peace and joy on account of their ignorance upon this subject. Our deliberate opinion is that faith in the righteousness of Christ, as the ground of justification, is the surest and highest source of Christian joy; and that without this no joy is abiding and pure. "Being justified by faith we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ: by whom also we have access by faith into this grace wherein we stand, and rejoice in hope of the glory of God."

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate