Menu
‹ Chapter 136 of 241 ›

On Plymouth Brethrenism — By G. Rogers

12 min read · Chapter 136 of 241
On Plymouth Brethrenism — By G. Rogers

UNDER this title we remember a society to have risen many years ago which, on account of its pretensions to superior piety, and the countenance it received from a few distinguished individuals, excited much attention, both in the Church and the world. By its advocates it was hailed as the commencement of a new era in Christianity, as the dawn of a second Reformation, and as the immediate pre-

283

cursor of millennial glory; while Christians in general looked on with mingled doubt and approbation, and wisely determined to suspend their judgment until the new movement had been tested by experience. It soon became evident that it was far more imposing in theory than in practice; and that it failed most in the very points in which it professed to be most pure. It assumed to be no sect, but to be pure Bible-Christianity, which was either the most childish fiction, or the most uncharitable presumption. It must have embraced either all Christians in the world, or a part. If it refused to be considered a sect, or section, or part, it arrogantly assumed to be the whole. It professes to have the true apostolic creed, and yet no sect, perhaps, for its size and period of duration, is more divided in its doctrinal views. It pretends to have made the Bible its own and only interpreter, and yet it appeals to the sentiments of its leaders with all the confidence that others have displayed in similar circumstances. In theory, it has no minister; in practice, it has many. In theory, it is a most united body; in reality, it is most divided. On these accounts, considering its high pretentions, and how completely they have failed, it may be affirmed, without any violation of charity, to have been weighed in the balance, and found wanting. After many years, it is scarcely more extensive than soon after its origin, and certainly is in less general repute.

In the spiritual, as well as in the natural world, causes have their own effects, or, in other words, "Whatsoever a man soweth that shall he also reap." A great mixture of truth and error has been sown in the field we are now surveying, and a plentiful crop of both has appeared; but the tares, to our thinking, are in unusual proportion to the wheat. New sects have generally branched off at some neglected point of doctrine or discipline in the Christian Church. Where the deficiency has been most felt, efforts have been made to supply it. Those efforts have been made with sincere motives, but have not, perhaps, on account of the unofficial source from whence they came, received the attention they deserve; or they may not have had a full response in the minds and hearts of fellow Christians. In either case distinction is conferred upon the author of the change. If he be a man whose strength is not equal to his day, and whose humility does not increase with his reputation, he will be seen unduly to magnify both himself and his suggested improvement to the discomfort of his brethren, and commonly to a final separation from them. Accompanied by a few others he forms a community upon new principles, necessarily based upon the peculiarity of his own religious views. In this way, that which was good at first is carried to excess, and becomes a positive evil; less evil in itself than in the irregularities and errors with which in the hands of the ignorant and self-conceited it is accompanied.

In circumstances like these, Plymouth Brethrenism had its origin. It was a revival of the ancient sect of the Bereans, who "searched the Scriptures daily to see whether these things were so." In every age of the Church, men have been too ready to take the truths of Scripture from the lips of the preacher second-hand, instead of deriving them from the Scriptures themselves. They have been content with the stream, when they might have repaired to the fountain. They

have been guided and pleased with the reflection, when they might have gazed upon the source of the light. In some cases, this is unavoidable; but, as a test of truth, the living preacher is never to be preferred to the written Word. To the twelve, Jesus could say, "He that heareth you, heareth me," because they were inspired to make known what he had taught them to others, and the New Testament at first was in preaching only. As that authority was gradually withdrawn, the more sure word of prophecy was gradually introduced, until the Church was left wholly to the authority of the inspired record. The assumption of authority in pastors and teachers equal to the written Word has been the source of incalculable evils, both in the Church and the world. The only security for the preservation of the Gospel, as taught by Christ and his apostles, in after ages, was in the New-Testament Scriptures. Its teachers had to invent nothing; they were neither to add unto the things written in this book, nor to take from them; they were to interpret, explain, and enforce, the volume of Inspiration, as men of science have to do with the volume of Nature. The same rule holds good now, as in the time of Isaiah, and will to the end of the world: "To the law and to the testimony: if they speak not according to this Word, it is because there is no light in them." Such a standard of appeal was absolutely needful, and it was indispensable that it should be within the reach of all, or how could hearers know for certainty what they ought to believe, when their teachers often differed from each other, and sometimes from themselves? Ministers are not, therefore, substitutes for the Bible, but its interpreters. They can claim no authority for their teaching, except so far as it is the teaching of the written Word. They do not supersede, but render more needful, the study of the Scriptures by their hearers for themselves.

On this point the new sect took their stand. Hearers were too ready to put their teachers in the place of the Scriptures they taught. The Bible itself was greatly neglected by them. "Let us look into the Scriptures for ourselves," said one, "let us study it closely! Let us examine it as our teachers have done!" "Well said," replied another. A social party is then formed for the purpose. It is found to be profitable and reviving. It increases. New parties are formed for the study of the Word of God only. This was an admirable appendage to the hearing of the Word, and other parts of public ordinances; and such as we would highly recommend to all Christian people. The Scriptures cannot be too much studied by our hearers; and we would urge them to its study in the original languages as far as ever they may be inclined to go. Would God that all the Lord's people were learned in the Scriptures! This goodly practice, however, soon became abused. From an auxiliary, it was made the principal thing: a part was magnified to a whole. Separation from other means of grace followed; an internal government of its own was instituted; and within its own little sphere, all true Christian doctrine and discipline were contained. Under this delusive exterior, it must be admitted, there were instances of piety not unworthy of primitive simplicity, in superiority to the pleasures of the world, in love to the brethren, and in the continual cultivation of a spirit of devotion by the Word of God and by prayer. The goodness, however, was counterbalanced by enormous evils. The

285

system carried within itself the elements of its own dissolution. These elements were the disavowal of all divinely-constituted offices in the Church of Christ, except such as existed amongst themselves; the refusal to unite in acts of religious worship with those who were not of their own party; the confusion both of sentiment and of discipline inseparable from an equality of teachers; and the incapacity of the most forward to teach those who were more inclined to hear. As might naturally be expected, every one sought for new interpretations and new doctrines. The old paths were rejected because they were old. They who could not walk side by side with others, must make for themselves new paths. Hence the distinguishing doctrines of the gospel with them, as a rule, are of secondary import, except as far as they can find them concealed under types and historic events where none had found them before; and hence every shade of opinion in relation to the millennium, the second advent, and to prophecy, finds zealous supporters amongst them. Their great fault as Biblical interpreters, in that in which they most pride themselves, has even been, and still is, to the best of our belief, the confidence reposed in their own impression of the meaning of any part of Scripture as the true one, because it has been forcibly revealed to their minds, as they suppose, by the Spirit of God, and has been to them the source of much profit and consolation. "The spirits of the prophets are subject to the prophets," is a rule not acted upon by them. The spirit of prophecy in one is never contrary to the spirit of prophecy in another; and yet it not unfrequently happens that one has had a revelation of a very opposite meaning of the same passage from that which has been revealed to another. Interpreters of impulse, or of supposed special teaching, are sure to differ greatly from each other. "How is it then, brethren? When ye come together, every one hath a psalm, hath a doctrine, hath a tongue, hath a revelation, hath an interpretation. Let all things be done unto edifying." God is not the author of confusion either in doctrine or discipline. From social parties with the Bible in their hands, competent to its critical interpretation, with a single eye to the discovery of "What is truth?" and bowing implicitly to the teaching of the Word, nothing but good can arise; but from social parties for the study of the Scriptures under other circumstances, as in the case before us, we look for "evil, and only evil, and that continually."

Another instance in which Plymouth Brethrenism is unlike the brethrenism of old, and unlike the Church of Christ when true to its mission in any age, is, that it is essentially proselyting; gathering its converts from the Church, and not from the world. Some few, through social influences, may have been led to make it their first profession of true religion, but that is the exception, not the rule. It is parasitical, both in its origin and growth. It tracks the footsteps of the faithful servants of Christ, as certain Jewish teachers hung upon the rear of the Great Apostle in his prosperous mission to the Gentiles; not to console the new converts, but to trouble them; not to confirm, but unsettle; not to consolidate, but to disunite. That such has been the effect of the agents of this schism, in many towns and villages of our land, is well known. They have been robbers of Churches, not less stealthy in their movements, and in confidently claiming their plunder as

their own, than others of a similar profession. This is the natural effect of a theory which has no sympathy with any other Christianity than its own. We do not malign it, therefore, we simply state its true character, and its irresistible consequences. Is this now the Church that was to go out into the highways and hedges, and compel men to come in? Is this the stone cut out of the mountain, that is to grow till it fills the earth? For half a century it has been proclaiming itself to be the only true Church; during that period there has been nothing but divisions and every variation of opinion; and what is it now? This inquiry brings us to the occasion of these observations. A treatise has been forwarded to us, entitled, "The Heresies of the Plymouth Brethren, by Dr. Carson," in which the prevalent opinions of this sect at the present time, are carefully stated and explained. Dr. Carson is a medical practitioner at Coleraine, in Ireland, and well known as a zealous champion of the ancient orthodoxy. He is a clear and powerful controversialist, with less urbanity, perhaps, than might possibly consist with the boldest vindication of truth, and with too much of the spirit of exultation over a fallen foe. He that gives the last fatal blow, should not be the first to raise the shout of victory. We have deemed, however, the exposure of the heresies of the Plymouth Brethren in this pamphlet, worthy of a more extended notice than could be given by us in a review. In this we have sacrificed personal inclination to a sense of public duty. We believe the sentiments of this body are not generally known, as from the consciousness of perpetual change, they are never avowed by themselves as an established creed. It is more needful, therefore, that they should be published by others. We can speak of them only as contained in the writings of their professed advocates at the present time.

Upon the person of Christ, Dr. Carson has established the fact of an essential deviation from admitted truth. The humanity of Christ is not a humanity derived from man, or forming any part of that which is common to men, but in its whole material is heavenly and divine; not relatively merely, but substantially divine. This is a fair specimen of the mysticism in which their whole theology is shrouded, and the manner in which the very foundation-truths of Christianity are undermined by them. Upon the doctrine of the Atonement, the same mysticism prevails. Its virtue, we are told, consisted in the perfection of Christ's surrender of himself to God, rather than in the substitution of him for the guilty. This, if not a rejection, is a main step towards the rejection, of the propitiatory aspect of the death of Christ altogether. Upon the great subject of justification by the imputed righteousness of Christ, they are still more decidedly and extensively heretical. This is the surest test of evangelical purity. Every man must be justified to be glorified. Without a perfect righteousness there can be no justification; it would be a contradiction in terms. That righteousness must be our own or another's. No one pretends to have a perfect righteousness of his own. If then he has not another's, he cannot be justified. If he has another's, it can be by imputation only. The righteousness of Christ which was perfect, infinite in value because the obedience of the lawgiver to his own law, and not needed by himself, is that righteousness which can be imputed to others. These are simple and plain gospel-truths. Like all other vital truths, they are seriously

287

tampered with by the Plymouth Brethren. Imputation of righteousness is not denied by them. The righteousness imputed is the point on which they err. This is not the righteousness of Christ but of God. It is God's own righteousness, and not that acquired by the voluntary obedience of his Son, by which man is justified. This is subversive, not of the gospel merely, but of common sense. The righteousness of the Creator is not of the same kind as that of the creature; the one is a righteousness to command, the other a righteousness to obey. How then could the one be substituted in the place of the other? If the righteousness of the Lawgiver could be imputed, why not the righteousness of the Law itself, for they are substantially the same? Admit the righteousness of Christ to be of God, because appointed by him and procured by him who was both God and man, and all is intelligible and satisfactory.

We could not have believed the brethren to have so grievously erred upon this fundamental truth, had we not learned it from their own accredited writers. It is not without reason, therefore, that we raise a warning voice against them, and this is obviously required by the faithful use of "The Sword and the Trowel."

Upon the "Pastoral Office," our contemporaries differ widely from others. The one-man system, as it is sometimes styled by them, is highly offensive. It were easy to show how imperceptibly they have often fallen into the measure they condemn; and how the love of authority among them has been "the root of all evil; which, while some coveted after, they have erred from the faith, and pierced themselves through with many sorrows." It is surprising, however, that such sentiments should be seriously maintained by those who profess to make the Scriptures their only guide. It is most obvious to all but themselves that their views of Church government have been suggested by the peculiarity of their position, and Scripture has been bribed and coerced to accord with them. In no part of his pamphlet has Dr. Carson been more happy than in reasoning with them, upon this point, out of the Scriptures.

Upon the work of the Spirit and upon the Law, as a rule of life, similar peculiarities are detected and exposed; for which and, indeed, for the whole statements of this article we must refer our readers to the treatise itself. Enough has been said, we trust, to call attention to the subject. We write not uncharitably, but in the spirit of that charity that rejoices in the truth. Let the Plymouth brethren come fairly out, like other sects, and not hide themselves in secret places. Let them tell us what their creed is, and if it varies with the times and the seasons, let the variations be noted and published as in every other fluctuating scale. We have some respect for all who have decided principles, and are consistent with them. We love sincerity in religion, wherever it is found. We are glad to reason with all who are prepared to meet us on equal terms. We conclude, they must have but a little religion who wish to keep it all to themselves. We would advise such to associate freely with other Christians, in the full persuasion that they will receive far more benefit than they can confer; and that when for the time they ought to be teachers, they have need that one teach him again which be the first principles of the oracles of God.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate