William Plumer

William Plumer

2 Sermons
William Swan Plumer (July 26, 1802 – October 22, 1880) was an American preacher, theologian, and author whose intellectual leadership within the Presbyterian Church shaped 19th-century American evangelicalism. Born in Greersburg (now Darlington), Pennsylvania, to William Plumer and Catharine McAlester, he grew up in a frontier family of modest means. After graduating from Washington College (now Washington & Lee University) in Virginia in 1825, he studied at Princeton Theological Seminary, where he was licensed to preach by the Presbytery of New Brunswick in 1826 and ordained as an evangelist by Orange Presbytery in 1827. Marrying Eliza Garden Hassell in 1829, he began a ministry that spanned over 50 years, fathering two daughters who survived him. Plumer’s preaching career included significant pastorates: First Presbyterian Church in Richmond, Virginia (1834–1846), where he founded The Watchman of the South newspaper; Franklin Street Presbyterian Church in Baltimore, Maryland (1847–1854); Central Presbyterian Church in Allegheny, Pennsylvania (1854–1862), alongside teaching at Western Theological Seminary; and shorter terms in Philadelphia and Pottsville. Known for his plain yet profound sermons, he moderated the Presbyterian General Assembly in 1838 (Old School) and 1871 (Southern branch), advocating Old School theology amid denominational splits. His refusal to take a Union stance during the Civil War—praying only for peace, not victory—branded him a “traitor” in the North, prompting his move south in 1867 to teach at Columbia Theological Seminary in South Carolina until 1880, as Professor of Didactic, Polemic, and Pastoral Theology.
  • Sermons
  • Bio