SermonIndex Audio Sermons
Image Map
Discussion Forum : News and Current Events : C. S. Lewis 'opposed live Narnia film'

Print Thread (PDF)


Joined: 2002/12/11
Posts: 37629
"Pilgrim and Sojourner." - 1 Peter 2:11

 C. S. Lewis 'opposed live Narnia film'


A newly-revealed letter by author CS Lewis has shown he opposed the idea of a screen version of his Narnia books, now adapted for a major film.
Lewis said TV versions of the animals in his books would result in either "buffoonery or nightmare" and criticised Walt Disney for "vulgarity".

The letter, written in 1959, has been published on a literary website.

A BBC TV series was shown in 1988 while the Disney film is out on 8 December. Lewis' estate approved both projects.

Lewis made the comments in a letter to BBC producer Lance Sieveking, who had made a radio adaptation of The Magician's Nephew - the prequel to The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe - which met the author's approval.

SI Moderator - Greg Gordon

 2005/11/30 23:36Profile

Joined: 2005/7/3
Posts: 233
Lancashire, England

 Re: C. S. Lewis 'opposed live Narnia film'

i found this quote to have quite an impact on me concerning this issue

C.S. Lewis said:

"Cartoons (if only Disney did not combine so much vulgarity with his genius!) would be another matter. [b]A human, pantomime, Aslan would be, to me, blasphemy.[/b]"

aren't they now planning a musical version presumably not with an actual lion or a CGI one!

found here: [url=]C.S. Lewis opposed screen 'Narnia'[/url]



 2005/12/1 3:16Profile


Earlier this year, I read part of CS Lewis's autobiography, in which he describes his passion for drawing imaginative animals-in-action, when he was a small boy. This is what he carried into his writing of the Narnia Chronicles, I believe.

Two days ago, on BBC radio fivelive at the end of the midday news (I can't find a clip.) Lewis's stepson, who has co-produced the film about to be released, was interviewed.

In a very short space, he explained how much has changed since 1959 when Lewis's original comments [i]against[/i] film, were made. He also clarified that the Naria Chronicles were [u]never[/u] written as an allegory to Christianity or with Christology in mind - they were about a fictional world into which 'evil' had 'crept', which needed a god to save them.

Much to my joy, he managed to squeeze in 'just as God had to come and save ours' which got me laughing and shouting praises round my kitchen!

As he said this in the middle of sentence and it was a live interview, this 1.3s of it will be there for posterity, I seriously trust. :-) Amen.

Of the film, Disney is distributing it [u]only[/u]. It has been drawn and manufactured by a different company, using the very latest animation techniques, thus meeting CS Lewis's imagined high standard of excellence.

 2005/12/1 4:11

Joined: 2005/7/5
Posts: 382
The Netherlands

 Re: What is Narnia about?

Not having read his Narnia books, I am wondering what the difference of this is with for example 'The Lord of the Rings'.
That was a movie which I found cool to watch but that was before my conversion. Nowadays I'd rather not watch it as it doesn't feel good. (I doubt that God enjoys us being entertained by watching imaginary creatures using some sort of magic from an unknown source)

My first and only book I read from C.S. Lewis was called: 'The problem of pain'. Back then I didn't knew that C.S. Lewis also wrote 'fictional' books or what Narnia was. :-)

Well what are your people's thoughts about this?

[edit]I'll move this post to the Lounge.

Jonathan Veldhuis

 2005/12/1 17:28Profile

Promoting Genuine Biblical Revival.
Affiliate Disclosure | Privacy Policy