Poster | Thread |
PraiseB2God Member

Joined: 2008/2/14 Posts: 2
| Sinners Prayer?? Good or Bad?? | | Can anyone tell me anything about the sinners prayer? Origins?
Is it Biblical to use the sinners prayer?
I have looked it up but can only find one article that everyone quotes and posts called The Sinner's Prayer: "Modern apostasy and false teaching that prevents men from being saved."
What is everyones thoughts on this subject?
Thanks! |
|
2008/2/14 1:02 | Profile |
poet Member

Joined: 2007/2/16 Posts: 231 Longview WA
| Re: Sinners Prayer?? Good or Bad?? | | The sinners prayer probably originates from the early protestant days, Luther and the like.
A prayer alone will not justify us before a holy God. But When we realise that we as sinners, need to be saved from judgment, If we confess our sins, repent from our sins, meaning change our mind and stop our sinfull behavior. God will forgive us and restore us to a right relationship with Him. A prayer of some formula will give us the general Idea to what we should be thinking about and correcting in our lives. But by Just saying a prayer and not makeing any changes in our Lives, or Christ indwelling us and causing us to make changes in our lives, the prayer is just useless and pointless.
_________________ howard
|
|
2008/2/14 6:19 | Profile |
hisremnant Member

Joined: 2006/2/2 Posts: 55 North Central Indiana
| Re: | | Praise Jesus!! Lion of Judah!!!
i will be the first to say that the begining of a persons life in Christ often begins in prayer. It [b]must however come from a broken and contrite heart[/b]. We must fully understand that we are condemned by our sins.
Today many of the responses are emotional and not from the heart. People take out fire insurance and then live like hell, having a false assurance of their position before God.
As to your question it is my understanding that the idea of a sinners prayer "asking Jesus into your heart" started with Dwight Moody in the late 19th century.
"Alter calls" reportedly had there initiation with Charles Finney.
Hisservant rich
Matthew 4:17 |
|
2008/2/14 9:34 | Profile |
Miccah Member

Joined: 2007/9/13 Posts: 1752 Wisconsin
| Re: Sinners Prayer?? Good or Bad?? | | PraiseB2God wrote:
Quote:
What is everyones thoughts on this subject?
I tremble at the thought of people standing infront of our Lord with only this as the testimony of their faith and belief in Him. _________________ Christiaan
|
|
2008/2/14 11:01 | Profile |
jgraves11 Member

Joined: 2008/1/26 Posts: 55 Munford, TN
| Re: | | I am a pastor in the bible belt. The sinners prayer has become one of the greatest hindrances to sharing the gospel. Everyone you share with has been "saved" "prayed the prayer" 10 to 20 times. I understand that it makes it easier to say that someone has been saved then they have this assurance in the prayer that they prayed. It seems that it is used to replace God's grace in salvation. Now people only perform this sacrament and God has to save them, according the sinner's prayer mentatility. Sorry if I am a little harsh, I have been very frustrated with this situation for a long time. their is a lot more that could be said on the subject but I think you get the point. _________________ John Graves
|
|
2008/2/14 11:07 | Profile |
PreachParsly Member

Joined: 2005/1/14 Posts: 2164 Arkansas
| Re: | | Quote:
jgraves11 wrote: I am a pastor in the bible belt. The sinners prayer has become one of the greatest hindrances to sharing the gospel. Everyone you share with has been "saved" "prayed the prayer" 10 to 20 times. I understand that it makes it easier to say that someone has been saved then they have this assurance in the prayer that they prayed. It seems that it is used to replace God's grace in salvation. Now people only perform this sacrament and God has to save them, according the sinner's prayer mentatility. Sorry if I am a little harsh, I have been very frustrated with this situation for a long time. their is a lot more that could be said on the subject but I think you get the point.
Amen brother. Some people in the Bible belt are having the very life choked out of them by that belt! People need a confrontation with God and then a conscious reality of being born of the Spirit. _________________ Josh Parsley
|
|
2008/2/14 11:23 | Profile |
hisremnant Member

Joined: 2006/2/2 Posts: 55 North Central Indiana
| Re: | | Praise Jesus!! Lion of Judah!!!!
Amen!! jgraves11
Mt 15:6 then he need not honor his father or mother.' Thus you have made the commandment of God of no effect by your tradition. Mt 15:7 "Hypocrites! Well did Isaiah prophesy about you, saying: Mt 15:8 'These people draw near to Me with their mouth, And honor Me with their lips, But their heart is far from Me. Mt 15:9 And in vain they worship Me, Teaching as doctrines the commandments of men.' "
i see this all the time sin hardened criminals who a claim to have long been saved because he [b]"said the prayer"[/b]
When i go in to the jails or out into the streets i am frequently asked to [b]say the prayer[/b] Which i never do.
i speak to them about repentance and the cost of following Christ. i tell them we serve God because HE is worthy of all we could ever do.
i do not sell Jesus like a new car!!
Hisservant rich
Matthew 4:17
|
|
2008/2/14 11:35 | Profile |
washad Member

Joined: 2007/11/15 Posts: 47 arkansas
| Re: | | Question. Don't we all say the sinners prayer? When God reveals himself in his majesty. When he reveals to us our sinful, vile selves. When we are crushed by the weight of our transgressions and his incomparable mercy and grace. When we see Jesus as our sacrifice and only hope. Do we not call on Jesus holy name and plead for mercy and forgiveness? Do we not pledge our lives to Him unreservedly? Are we not sinners saying a prayer? It just seems that we are putting down the prayer rather than the motive. I agree that prayer should no be coerced nor should we be salesmen of Jesus looking only for "converts". But a true sinners prayer can be of great comfort in times of opression and trials when doubts may come. We should not be the cause of more doubt by questioning the idea of linking salvation and prayer. some of my thoughts- washad _________________ jonathan
|
|
2008/2/14 13:36 | Profile |
sojourner7 Member

Joined: 2007/6/27 Posts: 1573 Omaha, NE
| Re: Sinners Prayer?? Good or Bad?? | | The sinner's prayer originates with Jesus parable of the proud publican and the broken man. It is as simple as it is heartfelt: God be merciful to me, a sinner. If the heart is sincere and the conviction is true; God will not fail to answer!! _________________ Martin G. Smith
|
|
2008/2/14 13:40 | Profile |
PreachParsly Member

Joined: 2005/1/14 Posts: 2164 Arkansas
| Re: | | Quote:
washad wrote: Question. Don't we all say the sinners prayer? When God reveals himself in his majesty. When he reveals to us our sinful, vile selves. When we are crushed by the weight of our transgressions and his incomparable mercy and grace. When we see Jesus as our sacrifice and only hope. Do we not call on Jesus holy name and plead for mercy and forgiveness? Do we not pledge our lives to Him unreservedly? Are we not sinners saying a prayer? It just seems that we are putting down the prayer rather than the motive. I agree that prayer should no be coerced nor should we be salesmen of Jesus looking only for "converts". But a true sinners prayer can be of great comfort in times of opression and trials when doubts may come. We should not be the cause of more doubt by questioning the idea of linking salvation and prayer. some of my thoughts- washad
Quote:
sojourner7 wrote: The sinner's prayer originates with Jesus parable of the proud publican and the broken man. It is as simple as it is heartfelt: God be merciful to me, a sinner. If the heart is sincere and the conviction is true; God will not fail to answer!!
What I am talking about and I think the original poster is the "repeat after me." No one is coming against praying to God.
Repeating a prayer after someone doesn't merit you anything in and of itself.
I've often wondered that if a person doesn't know what they need to do or say in a prayer if they even know enough to be saved. _________________ Josh Parsley
|
|
2008/2/14 15:09 | Profile |