SermonIndex Audio Sermons
SermonIndex - Promoting Revival to this Generation
Give To SermonIndex
Discussion Forum : General Topics : Western perspective on Home Fellowship

Print Thread (PDF)

Goto page ( Previous Page 1 | 2 )
PosterThread
savannah
Member



Joined: 2008/10/30
Posts: 2265


 Re: Western perspective on Home Fellowship




I found the following website helpful, I hope you and some others do as well;

http://ntrf.org/index.php/new-testament-church-practice/

 2017/2/15 7:54Profile
proudpapa
Member



Joined: 2012/5/13
Posts: 2936


 Re:

RE : /// I ask this because you seem to have come to a place of putting a lot of emphasis on church tradition and early church fathers, rather than just scripture. Surely if even quite early church traditions contradict the scriptures we should be careful not to follow their ways.///

I agree. The Scripture never tells us to read it through the lens of tradition, It acctually instructs just the opposite.

Reading the Scripture through the lens of tradition makes the Word of God of none effect.

Now we might read the Scriptures and see that church tradition is in agreement with our findings on certain points but we should never try to determine what truth is by simply searching what church tradition taught.

Another point : is that I have found basicly no continuity on almost any topic throughout recorded church history.

case in point :

Research Baptism and it's relation to Salvation compare what Ante-Nicene taught with that of what the reformers taught to that of what the Anabaptist taught to that of what George Fox and the Quakers taught to that of what the revivalist taught ?

clarity

 2017/2/15 9:43Profile
dolfan
Member



Joined: 2011/8/23
Posts: 1727
Tennessee, but my home's in Alabama

 Re:

Imagine, if you will, a rod and reel handle in the hands of a bass fisherman. He stands in the boat, backswings the rod over his shoulder a little and with an authoritative flick of his wrist and forearm he lands his lure in just the spot he aimed.

Now, imagine, if you will, a lure on the end of that line. It dangles several inches off the end of the rod. Tethered to that reel, the line is strung through the eyes and holds the lure closely. Then, the lure is swung across the shoulder of the fisherman and is violently airborne -- still tethered -- as it sails over the surface of the water and enters, missile like, ungloriously and unceremoniously onto the surface where it immediately breaks through and sinks into a murky batch of undergrowth. It is reeled back in fits and starts, sinking yet alternately being pulled upward against thick vegetation and dark water before being allowed to sink just a little once more before the next tug of the line that seems to control it.


Our practice of the New Testament body life is very much from the point of view of the lure. We are cast into darkness, but guided by something we really do not see except we catch a glimpse of a short stretch of this glowing line on occasion. We know we are being drawn. We know the line is our guide. We know someone is on the other end of it and is doing the drawing. We trust that this someone knows what it is doing, but we admit we don't really, really know. We really do not know what other lures on other lines at other times experience but we get some information and we can draw partial, fragmented and sketchy conclusions. If we look at what we know of the experiences of others lures on other lines at other times, and we look at our own experience, we may conclude that this whole exercise is rather pointless.

BUT. But... There is another point of view. It is that first one. The view from the boat. The view of the fisherman. We see him sometimes. He pulls us closely enough at intervals that we get very, very close to him. And, what he sees is something HE understands fully. He knows why he's in the boat. He knows why he has chosen us as his lures. He knows what equipment he has and what he is using in this particular place we find ourselves being cast and reeled over and again. He knows how to rig the line to keep us tied on, and he knows what he's doing with us. He artfully aims us. He knows how to maneuver the boat with his trolling motor to keep everything positioned in ways that we don't understand. And, every now and again, we catch hold of something in the water and he drags us through it with a fish in tow and he is very, very pleased with what he's done as he takes the fish off of us and does what he wants with it.

My point is this: We cannot depend on the experiences of other churches and other people in other times and other places to know what God is doing with us now. His Word speaks. His Spirit witnesses. The Son abides within. We hear and we obey. We have enough knowledge, enough sense, enough understanding from Him that we know He knows what He is doing, even now. Even now all these generations later, after a thousand lures have been used and put away and after the lines are renewed and the lakes and ponds and creeks change. It isn't our view of the early church that governs us. It is our view of the captain of our salvation, the one whose boat we are in, who casts us where it pleases Him and He brings us through whatever drags of darkness and moments of light.

It is a dangerous thing in these days of deception to overstate the importance of the writings of those of old outside of Scripture. They have some utility, yes. But, they were imperfect as we are imperfect. If we base our lives in Christ, our lives in the church of Jesus, on the reported and recorded experiences of others then or now, we are setting ourselves up for the very dangers 2 Tim. 3:1-5 warn us against.


_________________
Tim

 2017/2/15 10:24Profile
ThyKingCome
Member



Joined: 2011/4/19
Posts: 169
Southern CA

 Re:

Greetings all in the lovely and matchless name of our Lord Jesus. I would like to address the Original Post and also brother Greg.

I too have been involved personally in home fellowships and have met even with house church leaders and pastors who were seeking to implement house churches in our area in San Diego, CA.

What I see has also been shared by others, and that God can use both. We have such a propensity in our flesh to polarize between issues and draw lines in the sand and try and make everything “this or that” or “all or nothing”. Now, I am not talking about the deity of Christ or clear doctrine, but rather God’s purposes and methods in building His kingdom.

Let me say this plainly: God has and will employ means and use people to do things that I would never do or approve of!! Think of it!! Would you have solved a tax problem with a fish? Would you have sent the spies to stay with a prostitute in Jericho? Would you have anointed Samson, and then re-used him after his fall?? Would you have called Saul of Tarsus to serve you? Would you have put your own Son on a cross? Would you put your spit on someone’s eye to heal them? The list goes on and on and on. One thing is certain, God’s ways are not our ways and His thoughts so much higher than ours! Far be it for us to be more rigid and un-approving than God!

Additionally, God does not dwell in a temple any longer that is made of brick and mortar, (I know we all know this) so to act like He would depart from the “institutional church” ALL across the board is absolutely contradictory to His Name and His New Covenant promise. Can God be quenched in a local assembly? Most definitely, but who’s to say the little “institutional church” down the street can’t be brimming with the glory of God because the saints representing that fellowship are walking in the light of the Lord?

We want it to either be “institutional church” or “Home Fellowships”, but in all reality, doesn’t the Lord work in both and don’t we see them both in scripture? People would gather publicly in a place of worship that was central and large enough to provide a place of worship, and then when they wanted more intimate fellowship they would meet in houses and have food together and continue it on throughout the week? Seems simple enough to me! And yet, I have seen the “anti-institutional church” club so bleak and dreary on church buildings and gatherings and so intoxicated with their own pain, wounds and ‘prophetic insights’ that they appear to me to be just like Jonah, sitting on a hill outside the city waiting for God to destroy it so they will be vindicated. It’s almost like there are those who want to see God depart from the traditional church model so that their prophetic warnings and pronouncements of Ichabod will be justified. It’s very sad.

Listen beloved, I have been wounded deeply by church leadership and under the traditional model, but it would be SO WRONG for me to pitch a tent on the hill outside with Jonah. Think of where Jonah SHOULD HAVE BEEN…he should have been combing the streets of Ninevah offering hope to people and discipling the repentant. Instead he refused to take part in the way God was working because he didn’t like it!!

Here’s the truth, as long as the born again saints of God are gathering together in Jesus Name, God will always meet them whether they are in a house, in a barn, in a cave, in a tree, in a hotel, in a building that is designed for gatherings etc. I know of churches that rent out night clubs because they get a good price during off hours!

Just as there can be leadership abuse in the institutional church there certainly can be amongst house fellowships. As it’s already been said, often times it’s the disgruntled and wounded who are the biggest advocates of the house church only scene. I am not saying all house churches operate this way – absolutely not, there are precious gatherings of sincere believers in homes around the world and I praise Jesus for that. I just don’t believe God can be forced to choose sides, or that His Spirit is on one or the other. We must never stuff God into a little cage because the Lion of the Tribe of Judah will break out.

Brother Greg

Thank you for your ministry and labor in the Lord. I have grown so much from gleaning from the sermons and discussions on this website. It’s because of this ministry that I have become acquainted with many of the speakers that I never would have listened to before because they were from a different era and from a different circle. I always remember the quote from Leonard Ravenhill that “bee’s collect pollen from many flowers” and it’s true!! Because of this platform I have even become close friends with some dear servants of the Lord who have their messages on here, and we were able to connect as a result of it. I have read through the Principles book and I really really enjoyed it, and it was powerful in my life during the season I was considering planting a house church. But I do recall getting that sense in my spirit that it seemed like it was the “only” way, and that did not settle with me. I praise God that you have the spiritual elasticity to be stretched and continue to go forward with the Lord allowing him to shape and mold your thinking – this is what true humility is all about. Thank you for writing the letter that you wrote about this, bless you.

Personal Testimony Now

I am currently in fellowship at a large institutional church in <gasp> San Diego, CA area and I have been blown away by the Biblical position this church takes. We spend at least 50 minutes every Sunday in the Word, going through the scriptures expositionally. The men’s ministry that meets Monday is off the hook right now. There are over 150 men who come and invest their lives each week for 2 hours, and we are currently devoting 45 minutes to group prayer after we study through prayers in the Bible. The group I am in is 10-12 guys and we are texting each other all week long and praying for one another constantly. Home fellowships under the covering of a very gentle pastor meet throughout the week and you can meet in someone’s home and have fellowship on a personal level. Wednesday Night the kids have Bible club and learn the scriptures and offer parents the opportunity to go on dates and strengthen their marriages. Prayer every morning of the week, corporate prayer Thursday night.

Even now, they have constructed a scale model of the tabernacle for people to visit and tour and listen to a one hour Bible study through it and it’s like nothing I have ever done – it’s like you’re in a Bible study walking through Hebrews and seeing Christ in everything. I am not saying all this to boast in the church or make anyone feel ashamed in any way, but I am trying to highlight the fact that this is all taking place at an “institutional church”.

Please understand my heart in this! Let’s endeavor to embrace unity in the Spirit on this one, and trust Jesus to work inside and outside the walls, conventionally and unconventionally. God is so much bigger than our view points and spiritual framework. I rejoice in being able to be a part of this kind of fellowship, but I don’t place my hope in it. Should persecution arise and become so fierce tomorrow that we can no longer meet in this way, this precious gathering of people here will disperse into homes and places throughout the city and seek to continue on in fellowship in Jesus’ Name. I hope and pray that if/when that day comes, that the house church only crowd will welcome us into their circles and not turn us out into the cold.

In Life Together, In Death with Him together, Redeemed by His Blood Together, One Together and always in Him.

-Kevin Bruce


_________________
Brother Kevin

 2017/2/15 13:45Profile
Sree
Member



Joined: 2011/8/20
Posts: 1953


 Re:

Quote:

What I see has also been shared by others, and that God can use both.



Yes I agree with most part of what you wrote.
Yes God can use both. I myself was born again through an institutional church.
But the fact that God can use someone does not mean he is pleased with them. God using something and God being pleased with something are 2 different things.

Quote:

Here’s the truth, as long as the born again saints of God are gathering together in Jesus Name, God will always meet them whether they are in a house, in a barn, in a cave, in a tree, in a hotel, in a building that is designed for gatherings etc. I know of churches that rent out night clubs because they get a good price during off hours!



Rev 3:20:- Behold, I stand at the door and knock; if anyone hears My voice and opens the door, I will come in to him and will dine with him, and he with Me.

The Lord was standing outside of Laodicea church. If Jesus will always gather with believers then he should be inside Laodicea Church. It only means that there are more conditions to Matt 18:20.

I am not saying insitituation churches do not have the presence of God. They may have but I do not believe all of them have it just because of Matt 18:20. I also do not believe all home fellowships have the presence of God as well.

My problem with most institutional churches is not just the lack of strong word or fellowship, it is also certain practices that are unbiblical. What about passing the offering box?

I heard that these Churches have to give a report of their attendees to banks to which they owe money. Now if they give the real count then most banks will increase their interest rates, hence to avoid it, they often fake the numbers to the banks. Just the way they are designed or setup makes them depend to much on inflow of money rather than God. As Jesus said one cannot serve both God and money. I think it is the love for money that will differentiate a true bride of Jesus from a fake bride.


_________________
Sreeram

 2017/2/15 22:49Profile
sermonindex
Moderator



Joined: 2002/12/11
Posts: 39795
Canada

Online!
 Re:

Quote:
Greg, Can I ask if you would agree that the scriptures are the only real reference we should take for how the Lord set up and wanted His church to function?

I ask this because you seem to have come to a place of putting a lot of emphasis on church tradition and early church fathers, rather than just scripture. Surely if even quite early church traditions contradict the scriptures we should be careful not to follow their ways.

I don't see Paul or Peter in anyway supporting hieratical leadership, but servant, plural leadership.




Dear brother,

From my post in this thread I am simply trying to state that we should consider ourselves as part of what God has been doing for 2000 years through Church history. Of course in this history is the good the bad and the ugly. Everything done in the name of Christ is not true Christianity.

The viewpoint that was held by George Fox and some others that right after the death of the apostles all of Christianity essentially apostated completely is something I currently do not hold to. I believe that there has always been apostate believers that have deviated from the truth. Even amongst Jesus 12 disciples, 1 Judas, fell away. Amongst the first 7 deacons that were instituted by the Apostles, 1 Nicolas of Antioch, fell away and began a false sect of believers and teachings.

But to say that the entire of Christianity fell into an apostate hierarchal system right after John the Apostle died approximately in aprox. AD. 100 is not historical or factual. As we can see in the very writings of Scriptures, there were struggles but always Churches that were following in the way of the Lord. We have no Bible verse that tells us a great apostasy happened right after the death of the Apostles.

False teachers and doctrines, that tear the body like wolves and seek to bring away people unto their strange new teachings and doctrines was the battle that the Church continues to fight in our day. With acceptance of the doctrine of restorationism, this opens the doors for any believe to state a new revelation of truth that the Apostles originally believed and declare all of christianity apostate between their new revelation and the death of the apostles. This is how almost all cult groups and some denominations have started.

The Lord has used some of these groups to recover a truth or expand the kingdom of God through missions and evangelism, but the damage overall with this thinking has caused more problems then solutions. One has to just look at the current scene of Christianity in the West to see this.

I believe a solution is to look back and find the rich fertile soil of where the Church began and then see throughout history of those who kept to this faith "once delivered to the saints" (Jude 1:9).

In my reading of Church history, the first 300 years of Christianity is very strong and powerful and they fought and won the victory over many false teachings and heresies that were seeking to destroy the faith of many. Of course as stated elsewhere men are men, even the Apostles were fallible and made many failures, mistakes and problems. Yet in the end all the Apostles were in agreeance with the truth of the Gospel and the traditions of the faith. What I mean by traditions are practices of the Church that were held and kept to, such as the Lord's Supper, Water Baptism, Head Coverings, Giving to the Poor, and others.

The danger in our day is we are trying to find our way looking at 250+ years of evangelical history in America instead of comparing the whole. This is how house churches easily can dismiss the Lord's Supper, The Trinity, Incarnation of Christ even Water Baptism or other things the Church has always held to.


_________________
SI Moderator - Greg Gordon

 2017/2/16 9:34Profile
Heydave
Member



Joined: 2008/4/12
Posts: 1306
Hampshire, UK

 Re:

Greg,

Thanks for your reply. I pretty much agree with everything you have written in it. I was in no way suggested that the whole church became apostate in the first or second century and that now we need to restore a newly restored truth. Yes that is deception.

Maybe we are thinking on different issues. I was just thinking about what to me is clear teaching in scripture regarding things such as plurality of eldership, servant leadership and no hieratical structure (not lording it over the flock). So where the early church fathers introduced practices that were clearly different to what is 'written' we must choose God's word I think.

Some of the terms used in today's church are not supported by scripture, such as 'Pastor' There is no 'Pastor' titled position in scripture. To 'pastor' is a verb and what elders should be doing, i.e shepherding (watching and feeding the flock). There is no 'Bishop' postion in scripture. The word is 'overseer' and is used interchangeably with Elder as it is what an Elder does (oversee). Some of the practices in Church history have kept traditions that nullify the word of God.

All that said, I do believe God still worked and does work mightily in the traditional church structures, even if I see them as not perfect. Just as well as none of us are perfect in all out understanding and God still uses us!


_________________
Dave

 2017/2/16 10:01Profile
dolfan
Member



Joined: 2011/8/23
Posts: 1727
Tennessee, but my home's in Alabama

 Re:

The criticisms of the Western "corporate church" (by whatever name you prefer) are valid. But, the house church 'movement' (such as it is) in America is an imperfect response. On balance, at least in my own opinion, the home based fellowship is far and away preferable still.

That is not to say there are not exceptions. Some corporate churches have thriving smaller sets of genuine fellowship and NT gifts and leadership operating in varying degrees in them. The larger church fellowship gives structure and help to these in some cases. I am aware of a church in Virginia, also, that is giving itself very fully to discipling its people to treat their homes AS churches, their families AS disciples.

Personally, the thought of being part of a Sunday-corporate-brick-and-mortar church again makes my stomach turn. It breaks my heart. I have gotten spoiled in our little fellowship at our house, but the day is coming pretty soon when that just won't happen anymore. We'll leave and we'll have to do something. In my own heart, it is settling for far, far less than we're called to whenever we darken the doorstep of any established church congregation.

But, I've pretty much given up any fight I've had in me to say to those around me that Americanism has so infected our churches that we can't get to anything approaching NT life in His body. I don't have it in me anymore. Unless the Lord does something along these lines to surprise me --- and He may, you never know --- whenever we move, I will probably lead our little family to take a seat in a Sunday pew in a noise-filled room with electric guitars and hair-gelled pastors and youth pastors and money and hype and all the rest and go through the motions of a plastic-banana fellowship. Because, in the end, I'm not any different than any other schmuck in a pair of shoes.


_________________
Tim

 2017/2/16 12:27Profile
Heydave
Member



Joined: 2008/4/12
Posts: 1306
Hampshire, UK

 Re:

Hey Tim,

I know you are a better than man than that, to sell out so easily to such a thing as you describe! :)


_________________
Dave

 2017/2/16 13:34Profile





©2002-2024 SermonIndex.net
Promoting Revival to this Generation.
Privacy Policy