Saints, after reading the thread entitled "The Problem of the Modern Day Pastoral Role", I thought this lengthy article might be a good follow up:
How to Have a New Testament Church Meeting
by Rusty Entrekin
The Corinthians practiced what are called participatory, open, or interactive meetings. Should we imitate them in this regard?
Did you know that the Bible gives us guidelines on how to have a church meeting? These instructions are found in 1 Co 14:26-40.
1 Co 14:26 begins with What then shall we say, brothers? When you come together, everyone has a hymn, or a word of instruction, a revelation, a tongue or an interpretation.
In this verse, the apostle Paul was describing what normal church life was like for the Corinthians. It may come as a shock to us to realize he did not say, When you come together, the minister of music has a song, and the pastor has a word of instruction.
Instead, everyone of the brethren at Corinth came ready to contribute something. Some might think that the Apostle was criticizing the Corinthians for this. Perhaps there was some mild criticism intended, for as we read on, the apostle provides guidelines regarding who can speak, how often, and when. He restricted the number of those who could publicly speak in tongues and prophesy in a given meeting, and corrected the behavior of some of the women. But if there was any criticism intended in verse 26, it was quite limited. Paul did not go on to restrict the right to speak to only a few men. He did not say, "Brethren, this ought not to be. Only the pastor and the minister of music should speak." Instead, he assumed the right of any of the brethren to speak in the meeting, and simply provided guidelines for doing so. Thus, his intent was merely to provide some course corrections, not to cancel the entire flight!
This verse makes it startlingly clear that at Corinth, the right to publicly bring a teaching to the entire church was not the exclusive right of one paid professional. Pastors were not the only people who were allowed to bring a word of instruction during church, and ministers of music (had they existed back then) were not the only ones who introduced songs to sing!
In Col 3:16, we learn that things were apparently like that at Colosse, too:
Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly as you teach and admonish one another with all wisdom, and as you sing psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs with gratitude in your hearts to God.
Speak to one another, Paul also wrote in Eph 5:19-20, with psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs. Sing and make music in your heart to the Lord, always giving thanks to God the Father for everything, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ.
In the above verses, notice the emphasis on teaching one another, and singing to one another.
Reading this, it becomes painfully apparent that the way most of us have church today was not "normal" in New Testament times. Back then, church meetings were a time when the everyday, non-professional Christian contributed to the meetings. The right to teach in church was not the exclusive domain of the paid professional.
I see advantages in the way that the early Christians practiced church.
We often talk about the doctrine of the priesthood of the believer nowadays. But back then, they not only talked about it, they actually lived it out in how they practiced their church meetings.
It is tough for one man to meet the teaching needs of everyone in his congregation alone. Back then, more than one person taught in the meetings, so that was not a concern. And since church leaders got to hear teaching from others, it was less likely that they had unmet spiritual needs. Is there a church leader on earth who is so mature that he cannot benefit from the teaching of others in his church? I doubt it.
"But, brother, I can imagine someone objecting, we allow others with the gift of teaching to teach in Sunday School, not in church. Well, at least the members of your church have some outlet for teaching one another, and that's good. There were also opportunities to teach outside of church meetings in NT times. Something distantly kin to Sunday School, classes for new converts, arrived on the scene rather early. Paul held discussions daily in the Lecture Hall of Tyrannus, and others surely did similar things now and then. But Paul could not have been speaking of one of these ancient predecessors to Sunday School, because 14:23 makes it very clear that he was writing about when the whole church comes together! And we know that Sunday school, invented less than 250 years ago, could not have been what He had in mind! No doubt, Paul was talking about church meetings, for he used the word church seven times in this chapter!
And so we cannot avoid the conclusion that any man with the spiritual maturity to teach was welcome to bring a message in an early church meeting. In fact, since Paul does not limit the number of teachers who may speak, it probably often happened that more than one man would teach in a given meeting!
No doubt, church meetings were different back then. But were they better, or healthier? I think that they were, at least after Paul got the Corinthians straightened out with these instructions. Otherwise, in the verses that follow verse 26, Paul would have steered the Corinthians more toward our modern way of doing things. But he didn't!
Even more significantly, this epistle was addressed not only to the Corinthians, but to "all that in every place call upon the name of Jesus Christ our Lord". That would include us! Therefore, we cannot dismiss what Paul wrote in this passage with a wave of the hand, thinking, "This applied only to the Corinthians. It doesn't apply to me."
With these things in mind, let's go on to read these instructions that Paul wrote not only to the Corinthians, but to us as well.
Six Guidelines for Church Meetings
In 14:26, Paul gave examples of various contributions each believer may make to the meeting: "a hymn, or a word of instruction, a revelation, a tongue or an interpretation." In the verses that follow (27-40), he tells us how to incorporate these contributions into the meeting. Notice that the apostle does not give us an order of worship. Instead, he gives us principles and guidelines to follow which infuse freedom, spontaneity, and creativity into church meetings! Let's consider these guidelines.
The first guideline, in the last half of 14:26, is that All of these [songs, teachings, etc.] must be done for the strengthening of the church. Whatever is spoken in the meeting must edify, or strengthen, the church. Usually this entails speaking a positive and uplifting word, but a church may also ultimately be edified by a challenging word that produces sorrow and repentance.
The second guideline is If anyone speaks in a tongue, twoor at the most threeshould speak, one at a time, and someone must interpret. If there is no interpreter, the speaker should keep quiet in the church and speak to himself and to God (14:27). Unfortunately, because tongues is one of the more spectacular gifts, in modern times we have just as great a tendency to get off balance with it as the Corinthians did in their day. Pauls instructions are often ignored in several different ways, In some churches people speak publicly in tongues without an interpreter. In others, nearly everyone speaks publicly in tongues at once. Needless to say, this causes outsiders to think the church members are mentally unbalanced (1 Co 14:23)!
At the other extreme, in many churches speaking in tongues is not permitted at all, despite the fact that Paul makes allowance for it here, and despite the instruction he gave later in 14:39: do not forbid speaking in tongues. This is not to say that every church will have the gift of tongues, but according to verse 39, all churches should be open to its exercise according to Scripture. In fact, I know of a church composed mostly of cessationists (people who believe that the spiritual gifts of tongues and prophecy have ceased). Humbly recognizing that their belief in cessationism could be wrong, they say that they would permit a message in tongues to be spoken in their fellowship, out of fear of violating this clear command of scripture!
A third guideline is that Two or three prophets should speak, and the others should weigh carefully what is said (14:29). A prophecy, according to W.E. Vines Expository Dictionary, is the speaking forth of the mind and counsel of God. Thus prophecy is not limited to foretelling; it is more completely described as forth telling. Vine describes a prophet as having three primary characteristics: 1) the Spirit of God rests on him, 2) he converses with God, and 3) he is one from whom a message from God springs forth or is secretly disclosed.
The above verse should not be considered as a command that two or three prophets must speak, but rather as a command to allow two or three prophets to speak. Prophecy should not be forbidden, but we should weigh carefully what is said (14:29). Even when thus saith the Lord is attached to a message, we should not accept it unquestionably. God expects us to discern His Word from that which is not His, because false teaching and false prophecy are a real possibility. As 1 Th 5:19-21 tells us, Do not put out the Spirits fire; do not treat prophecies with contempt. Test everything. Hold on to the good.
Since the offices of teacher and prophet are treated as separate ministries in Eph 4:11, we should not consider teaching and prophecy to be the same thing. Teaching is usually based on learning and preparation; but prophecy is based on revelations of the Spirit. There is some overlap between the two, however, because 1 Co 14:31 tells us that instruction is one of the goals of prophecy. In fact, many of the spiritual gifts can overlap. A song, for instance, could teach doctrine, and an interpretation of a message in tongues could take the form of a prophecy. Likewise, a prophecy could take the form of a teaching, A good example of this is the prophecy given by King Lemuels mother to her son in Pr 31:1-31. Verse 1 refers to the passage as an oracle (lit., burden, a term often used in the OT to indicate a weighty message given by God), but it is written simply in the form of a mother teaching her son.
Peter wrote that Each one should use whatever gift he has received to serve others, faithfully administering Gods grace in its various forms. If anyone speaks, he should do it as one speaking the very words of God (1 Pe 4:10-11). Every word that is spoken in a church meeting should be prompted by the Spirit of God and delivered in a manner befitting such an utterance. Note also that we are commanded to use whatever spiritual gift God has given us to serve others, faithfully administering Gods grace (4:10). Spiritual gifts are not so much gifts to us as they are gifts to the body of Christ. Because of this, we would be harming the body of Christ if we denied others the opportunity to minister with their gifts! The beauty of a scriptural church meeting is that it gives God's people opportunities to do this.
In 1 Co 14:30 we read the fourth guideline: and if a revelation comes to someone who is sitting down, the first speaker should stop. There are several observations that we can draw from this verse.
First of all, we should recognize that the apostle is speaking of prophecy here, not of teaching. Some have misunderstood this verse, and taken it to mean that it is OK to rudely interrupt a teacher while He is delivering a word of instruction. Some have even taken it to mean that it is OK to change the course of a teaching altogether, or to interrupt with an entirely unrelated teaching! That would be very unedifying, and is not at all what the apostle meant here.
This does not mean that we cannot add some insightful comments to a teaching when appropriate, but when it is done, it should be done in respectful and edifying way. Avoid interrupting the Holy Spirit's flow during a teaching. You may want to wait until a teacher asks questions, or invites others to comment on the scripture passage he is teaching from. Or you may raise your hand and wait to be acknowledged, or wait for an appropriate pause in the teaching. The word that is translated revelation (14:30) means an unveiling of secrets given by the Spirit. Granted, one form that a revelation may take is when the Spirit gives a sudden understanding of a Bible passage or a scriptural principle to someone in a church meeting, who then shares it to complement a message that is being spoken. However, since Paul limits the number of prophets who speak to two or three, we must not besiege a teacher with so many revelations to compliment his message that the poor man cannot get through it. That would also be very unedifying.
Here, however, the apostle is not speaking of adding something to a teaching, but of how the Holy Spirit may move one prophet to speak, and then another. When the Holy Spirit desires a second prophet to speak, He is finished speaking, or almost finished speaking, through the first prophet for the time being, who should stop and give the second a chance to speak as soon as it is appropriate.
Note, also, that our Lord does not want one prophet to dominate the meeting. Other prophets, if there are any, should be given opportunity to speak.
Following this, Paul makes a corollary statement: For you can all prophesy in turn so that everyone may be instructed and encouraged (14:31). The prophets are to speak "in turn." One prophet must not interrupt another prophet so that two people are speaking at the same time. One rule that the apostle has made clear in this passage is that only one person should speak at a time. So even in the case of prophets, everything should be done in an orderly way. This obviously means that the second prophet should indicate to the first that he also has something to say, preferably by raising his hand or by some other silent signal.
Another principle evident here is that one persons gift cannot meet the needs of everyone. If we want everyone to be instructed and encouraged, then everyone must be allowed to participate in his proper turn. This principle of mutual participation means that there should be spontaneity in our meetings. No church meeting should ever be so planned that we do not permit the Holy Spirit to surprise us. We must allow Him room to sovereignly lead! Spontaneity and the freedom for anyone to speak add an air of excitement and expectancy to worship. The Lord never intended that church meetings be a boring experience!
However, our Lord did intend that church meetings be orderly. If someone speaks out of turn, then those who are spiritually mature should seek to restore order as quickly and discreetly as possible. Talking out of turn is speaking when the Holy Spirit has not led, and includes being disruptive, domineering, disorderly, long winded, or teaching falsehoods. Related to this, the apostle next teaches us that God gives no one an uncontrollable urge to speak: The spirits of the prophets are subject to the control of the prophets (14:32). If a person disturbs an otherwise orderly and edifying church meeting, then the urge to do so does not come from God. As Paul continues in v 33, For God is not a God of disorder but of peace.
A home meeting in New Testament times. Since the meetings were interactive and took place in homes, participants probably sat in a circle instead of rows.
A fifth guideline for meetings is based on 14:33b-35, As in all the congregations of the saints, women should remain silent in the churches. They are not allowed to speak, but must be submissive, as the Law says. If they want to inquire about something, they should ask their own husbands at home; for it is disgraceful for a woman to speak in the church.I could devote an entire book to discussing these two verses, and in fact, I have written a short book on this! My primary purpose in writing this article, however, is to encourage participatory church meetings, and experience has taught me that a discussion of this controversial passage tends to stand out in people's minds so much, that it overshadows everything else! Therefore, I am going to refrain from discussing it in this article. Suffice it to say, that unless the meetings had been participatory, the women would have been less tempted to violate this guideline.
The last guideline for church gatherings over-arches all else: But everything should be done in a fitting and orderly way (14:40). Spontaneity in church is no excuse for disorder! However, neither is doing things in a fitting and orderly way an excuse for squelching the Holy Spirit with a pre-printed "order of worship". Although there is room for scheduled events now and then, the tenor of this passage makes it clear that orderly (14:40) spontaneity is to be the standard!
Notice also the complete lack of emphasis on church leaders in 1 Co 14. They simply did not dominate the meeting. Certainly the leaders spoke up if a violation of the order of 1 Co 14 occurred, but otherwise they participated just like everyone else. Did you notice the cavalier way Paul tossed in a word of instruction with all the other elements of the meeting (1 Co 14:26)? Preaching as we know it today - one prescheduled teaching delivered as an oratorical performance - simply was not the emphasis of an early church meeting. Since everyone could potentially teach at any given meeting, most of the teachings were obviously not pre-scheduled. Certainly those inclined to teach would often prepare ahead of time, but that is not the same as always having someone slated to teach in advance. That kind of rigidity simply is not fitting (14:40)!
It is obvious from Scripture that church meetings were participatory in New Testament times, and that everyone was allowed to contribute freely and spontaneously to them. It is also obvious that Paul wrote these instructions not just for the Corinthians, but for our benefit as well, because the letter was addressed not only to them, but to "all that in every place call upon the name of Jesus Christ our Lord".
Since that is the case, many of us will find this passage threatening to our traditional church mindsets. You may even find this passage somewhat threatening to your career, if you, like me, were trained to be someone whose primary job is to bring "the" sermon Sunday morning and evening. Who wants to "shake the boat" and challenge "the way we've always done it"?
That certainly makes 1 Co 14:26-40 tempting to ignore, doesn't it?
Although we may wish to take that easy way out, the apostle Paul does not give us the comfortable option of ignoring his words, if we want to have a clear conscience. Instead, he goes on to tell us that what he is writing is the Lords command.
Did the Word of God originate with you? Or are you the only people it has reached? If anybody thinks he is a prophet or spiritually gifted, let him acknowledge that what I am writing to you is the Lords command. If he ignores this, he himself will be ignored (14:36).
Paul anticipated that there would be those who would want to conduct church meetings in ways other than this. His questions are designed to point out to them how presumptuous they would be to ignore his instructions and invent their own customsas though the Word of God had originated with them, or they had a corner on it!
We know for a fact, however, that there have been those in the history of the church who have presumed to substitute their own customs for the Word of God, since the way of meeting we have inherited is so different from what the Lord commanded. Tertullian, a late second century believer, wrote that custom without truth is error grown old.
The question is, are we going to continue ignoring God's word for the sake of "error grown old"?
If we intentionally did that, would not the words that Jesus spoke to the Pharisees ring accusingly in our own ears?
And why do you break the command of God for the sake of your tradition? (Mt 15:3).
Let's not look down on those who do not understand this passage, and therefore don't practice church this way. Many don't know better. They are merely continuing to abide by the traditions they have inherited. Besides, there may be other scripture passages that they understand and obey better than we do! Let's also not presume to judge those who understand this passage, but intentionally disregard it out of fear. Judgment is God's business. However, there is nothing wrong with encouraging such people to be more courageous!
Wealso don't want to lay an unbearable burden on those who attend churches that will not change. However, they will never know for sure that their church won't change until they try to get them to follow this passage!
Some churches already follow these scriptural principles, but if you attend one that does not, here are some ideas that might help you to get your church to change:
1.Don't ask people to change without making certain that they understand the biblical basis for that change first. That can take time, lots of teaching (line upon line, precept upon precept), and prayer.
2.Don't be a rebel, or a grumbler or complainer. Be respectful of authority, polite, nonjudgmental, and loving at all times. If the leaders are not behind this change, it will be very difficult to implement it.
3.Be patient. It takes time to turn the Titantic around!
4.Recognize that there were several types of meetings in New Testament times. There were prayer meetings (Acts 12:12), small gatherings in homes (Acts 2:46), apostolic teaching meetings (Acts 19:9), and church meetings (I Co 14:26-40). There is room for all of them. If your church leaders think that there will be too much opposition to implementing participatory meetings during the Sunday morning service, perhaps it can be done on a Sunday or Wednesday night. Some churches have an "After Glow" meeting following a regular service for participatory sharing.
Another excellent option is to have participatory small group meetings. This is usually best done in home cell group meetings. Since the early church met in homes, this can give you a wonderful taste of what New Testament Church life was really like! However, any small group meeting, from a Sunday School class to a youth group, can be made more participatory.
Since the Lord gave us these scriptural instructions for the sake of our spiritual health, any implementation of these scriptural principles can help to foster a healthier functioning church body that affirms the priesthood of the believer not only in word, but in deed.
5.If the ideas above fall on deaf ears, and you have leadership gifts or know someone who does, you could, as a last resort, pray about organizing your own small group meeting as a personal ministry. You don't have to break away from your church to do this.
If all of these options fail and you are attending the church God wants you to be at, it's not the end of the world! You should give it more time and prayer. Meanwhile, you can still get a lot of benefit from church meetings done the modern way.
Sometimes people simply won't change. Appropriately, Paul's next words are,
"But if any man be ignorant, let him be ignorant,"
If someone stubbornly chooses to ignore the sound instructions that the Apostle has given, there is no need to fret about it, or to keep pestering him. We are instructed to let him to remain in his willfully ignorant state.
Paul concludes with, "Wherefore, brethren, covet to prophesy, and forbid not to speak with tongues. Let all things be done decently, and in order."
If you implement the apostle Pauls instructions in your own church, God will be more pleased with your obedience than with the sweat and toil used to prepare for a thousand church meetings not conducted according to His Word. As the prophet Samuel said to King Saul, to obey is better than sacrifice (1 Sa 15:22).
The New Testament Way to Meet
How is it then, brethren? When ye come together, everyone of you hath a psalm, hath a doctrine, hath a tongue, hath a revelation, hath an interpretation. Let all things be done unto edifying.
If any man speak in an unknown tongue, let it be by two or at the most by three, and that by course, and let one interpret. But if there be no interpreter, let him keep silence in the church; and let him speak to himself, and to God.
Let the prophets speak two or three, and let the other judge. If anything be revealed to another that sitteth by, let the first hold his peace. For ye may all prophesy one by one, that all may learn, and all may be comforted. And the spirits of the prophets are subject to the prophets. For God is not the author of confusion, but of peace, as in all the churches of the saints.
Let your women keep silence in the churches: for it is not permitted unto them to speak; but they are commanded to be under obedience, as also saith the law. And if they will learn anything, let them ask their husbands at home: for it is a shame for a woman to speak in the church. What! Came the word of God out from you? Or came it to you only?
If any man think himself to be a prophet, or spiritual, let him acknowledge that the things that I write unto you are the commandments of the Lord. But if any man be ignorant, let him be ignorant.
Wherefore, brethren, covet to prophesy, and forbid not to speak with tongues. Let all things be done decently, and in order.
1 Co 14:26-40 (KJV)
Our Modern Way of Meeting
How is it then, brethren? When ye come together, the pastor hath a doctrine, and the minister of music hath psalms. Let all things be done unto edifying.
If anyone besides the pastor hath a doctrine, let him not speak; let him hold his peace. Let him sit in the pew, and face the back of the neck of the person which sitteth ahead of him.
Let the people keep silence in the churches: for it is not permitted unto them to speak; but they are commanded to be under obedience, as also saith church tradition. But if they will learn anything, let them ask their pastor after the service, for it is a shame for a layman to speak in the church. For the pastor, he hath a seminary degree, and the layman, he hath not so lofty a degree.
If any man desire to remain a church member in good standing, let him acknowledge that what I write to you is the command of the denominational headquarters. But if any man ignore this, he shall be promptly escorted out the door by the ushers.
Wherefore brothers, covet not to speak in the church. Let all things be done decently and in the order in which it hath been written in the church bulletin.
Marshall "Rusty" Entrekin and his wife Julie have seven children. He is a B.A. theology graduate of Louisiana College (SBC), where he was an active preacher in the BSU preaching team. He has served as an interim pastor, and on the staff of a church in Louisiana. Since then, Rusty has been a leader in teams that started several house churches in North www.christhomefellowship.org